My children have had baby dolls with countless accessories, and they enjoy using their imaginations and pretending to care for them. I have found these dolls to be an educational toy that helps to show them patience and nurturing.
In fact, baby dolls are great toys for children of any age or gender. They teach your little one how to interact with others while also giving them a sense of independence and responsibility. There are many different types of baby dolls, and some of these look very realistic. These will make your child feel like they are caring for a real person, just like you take care of them. The best part is that many adult baby doll buyers started as collectors when they were young.
There are many different options for realistic baby dolls, and I will cover all sorts of them. I will also share which dolls we started with at home, what their disadvantages were, and what I should have bought for my kids instead.
Carry on reading this page or jump straight to our number #1 pick on Amazon here.
Table of Contents
- What Should I Look for in a Baby Doll That Looks Real?
- Here’s How I’ve Determined the Best Realistic Baby Doll
- Our Top Picks for the Best Realistic Baby Doll of 2021
- Verdict: Your Best Baby Dolls That Look Real
What Should I Look for in a Baby Doll That Looks Real?
If you are shopping for a realistic baby doll, there are certain features that you should be looking for. Below you will find a list that I have come up with, which touches on every aspect that you can think of when it comes to baby dolls.
There are baby dolls that come with accessory sets and starter kits, while others don’t. For this list, I made sure that most of the ones that don’t come with a set or kit have options for extra clothes, a blanket, a bottle, and other things to purchase separately. It is always great to have that choice.
There are baby dolls that cry real tears, soil their diapers, and other things. Not many of them do this, but I included one that did for anyone who wanted their baby doll to have those functions. I know plenty of children that do.
The first thing you will look at will be the face. I only chose baby dolls that had the most realistic facial features.
Many of the realistic baby dolls are made of soft silicone or vinyl, which feel the closest to human skin. I took a look at what other people have said and found a variety of dolls to please all interests.
I believe it is very important to be inclusive. After all, we all look different, and it was important to me to find baby dolls that were available in multiple skin colors, like the Aori dolls.
Here’s How I’ve Determined the Best Realistic Baby Doll
I looked at a lot of reviews for each of the baby dolls on this list, and I chose the ones that were loved the most by other buyers and had the best features. I have owned several types of dolls throughout my life and I am still a collector today, so I had a basic idea of what I would want when looking for a realistic baby doll. Plus, I knew what would also be best for a child since that is probably who you are looking for. A sweet baby doll toy for your little one to care for all on their own.
Our Top Picks for the Best Realistic Baby Doll of 2021
#1: Aori Lifelike Realistic Reborn Baby Doll (Best Value)
Aori makes some of the most realistic baby dolls overall. I found that there were the most options available for ethnicity, gender, and overall look. I really enjoyed looking through their products because of the diversity. Keep reading to find out why this particular baby doll is our top pick.
It Has the Most Realistic Features
The first thing you will notice about this baby doll is how lifelike the face is compared to the other dolls on this list. This doll was handmade with care, including the eyes and the hair. Plus, this doll is 22 inches long, which is the average size of a real newborn baby. Your child will want to treat this baby with such affection because they will forget this is is just a soft, vinyl doll.
There Are a Lot of Doll Choices
This particular baby doll at the link above is the most popular, but there are more choices for ethnicity, gender, and hair color. There’s a good chance you’ll be able to find a doll with your own child’s features. These also show your child diversity, which is important to teach at any age. I will include a link here to an African American version of this Aori baby doll just to show you one of the many examples there are.
Here are more details of this realistic baby doll that are worth mentioning.
- It fits in newborn to 3 months baby clothes
- Package includes bottle, mat, birth certificate, outfit, plush, and a magnetic pacifier
- Meets ASTM safety requirements
- Cloth body with vinyl arms, legs, and head
- Ideal for age 3 years and up
This is a very highly rated realistic baby doll, and a lot of parents seem to agree that they love it as much as their kid does. For being just a doll, there was a lot of attention to detail and it is one of the most lifelike baby dolls that you can order. You will be very pleased when you get your baby home.
#2: Ashton-Drake Little Peanut Baby Doll (Best Premium)
Even though this baby doll is the most expensive, it is worth the money if you want something that is made of high quality. It has the look and feels of a real baby, just like our top pick. The real difference is that this particular doll was handmade by master artist Tasha Edenholm. Ashton-Drake is a company that has been in business for over 30 years, and they pride themselves on putting in the most care to all of the baby dolls that they make. Let’s talk about my favorite details of this baby doll.
The Arms and Legs Are Posable
A significant feature of this baby doll is being able to move the arms and legs, as well as the fingers. They are made of ultra-soft vinyl, which feels the most like real skin. The reviews that I saw of this doll all mentioned that it felt exactly like a newborn baby does. You can’t get any more realistic than that!
It Is Weighted to Feel Real
One of the most notable details of this baby doll is that it is weighted to feel just like a newborn baby. When you hold this doll, you will forget that it is just that. Not only is this doll perfect for children, but it is also great for a collector or anyone else who is looking for a lifelike baby doll.
What are other things that are great about this baby doll?
- All of the features are hand-painted
- 17 inches long
- Hand-rooted hair that feels real
- Recommended for age 12 months and up
One drawback of this baby doll is that it doesn’t come with any additional clothes and accessories like some of the others. However, this baby doll will fit in 0-3 month baby clothes, and most accessories that you can purchase separately will work as long as they are suitable for a 17-inch long doll. The price is high because of the handmade quality. If you want a doll that is the most realistic and you have the budget for it, then I would choose this one over the others like the Aori if you are a real collector.
#3: Baby Born Interactive Baby Doll (Best Gift)
Out of all of the other baby dolls on this list, this one probably looks the least lifelike. However, this may be because of the functions that it offers. You won’t see any other baby doll on this list that is quite like this one. Read on to see the reasons why I included this baby as the best gift for your child.
This Baby Acts Like a Real Baby
What is most impressive about this baby doll is that it actually performs physical functions like a real baby. It cries real tears, goes potty in the diaper or on the potty, and drinks bottles. You can also bathe this baby without damaging it. This doll will give your child the most authentic experience of what it is actually like taking care of a baby.
It Comes With Accessories and You Can Buy More
When you order this baby doll, you get several accessories, including an outfit, potty seat, bottle, and a birth certificate. The most unique accessory that comes with this doll is the interactive slice of cake. This makes it a perfect birthday gift for a child because then their new baby can celebrate with them.
Here are some more details of this doll.
- You can pose the baby for pictures
- When it lays down, its eyes close
- No batteries required
- Outfits and other accessories, like the bathtub, are sold separately
- Best for 2 years and up
I remember Baby Born being around for a really long time. When I was a kid, I actually owned one and remember it being my favorite toy for years. I always loved taking care of this doll, and I have the best memories of putting my baby in a stroller or feeding it breakfast and then changing a diaper. My favorite thing was having a birth certificate. I enjoyed the independence and responsibility, and I bet your child will, too. Plus, it comes at a very affordable price compared to some of the other lifelike dolls on this list.
#4: JC Toys African American La Baby Doll (Best Low Cost)
If you have a low budget and prefer a realistic baby doll with a smaller price tag, this could be a great option for you. It has some lifelike qualities but since it is lower cost, it won’t feel as real as most of the other babies. However, if you want a doll that is great for imaginative play, then this will still work great. Keep reading to learn some of the reasons why I believe this is the best low-cost baby doll.
There Are Diverse Options
When you follow the link to this baby, the first thing you will notice is that there are a lot of ethnicities available. Parents sometimes want the baby they choose for their child to match them, or they want to teach their children about different skin colors and racial backgrounds. These dolls are perfect for that.
It’s Safe, Non-Toxic, and Perfect for Younger Children
This baby is safe and non-toxic, making it great for toddlers and young kids. It is 16 inches long, which is the average size for a baby doll, making it easy for small hands to hold. Plus, it also has the National Parenting Center Seal of Approval.
Here are other things that are worth mentioning about this baby doll.
- BPA and phthalate-free
- Comes with one outfit, hat, and pacifier
- Additional clothes can be purchased
- Textured to feel like real skin
- Handmade in Spain
- Recommended for ages 1-15 years old
The way that this product was made compared to the other dolls, is slightly different as it is marketed for young kids to play with it and nurture. Lots of people have bought this baby for their babies to show them how to be kind and to learn more about life. Since it is very inexpensive, you can spend the extra money on other things for it. Just remember that you get what you pay for and this baby isn’t as realistic as some other others like the Aori or the Ashton-Drake.
#5: JC Toys Anatomically Correct La Newborn Baby Doll (Best Starter Baby Doll)
If your little one has never owned baby dolls before, this one may be a good fit. It is affordable at a mid-range cost, and you don’t just get the baby with purchase. It has intricate details, making it another baby at a good value if you don’t have a lot of money to spend. Let’s go over the reasons why I chose this as the best starter out of all of the other dolls.
She Is a “Real Girl”
Some people like to teach their kids about the differences between sexes at a young age, and this is one of the best dolls for that. As you can tell from the name, this baby is anatomically correct, so it has all of the parts that a female would have. If this doesn’t sound right for you, then you might be better suited for one of the other dolls. There is also a boy option that you can find here.
The Outfit and Blanket Are Hand Knitted
It’s details like this that make me fall in love with a product even more. The time spent making this beautiful outfit and blanket is definitely reflected in how it looks. You just know that whoever knitted them has real talent and skill.
What else does this toy baby have to offer?
- 15 inches long
- Made of safety tested and BPA free vinyl
- Comes with a pacifier, bottle, and birth certificate
- Recommended for ages 2-15 years old
JC Toys is a family-owned company from Spain, and they have been operating for 30 years. I have two of their dolls on this list because they are radically different and each has standout details that not only make them unique but make them special. Any of these dolls would make great gifts, including this one. I appreciate the handmade details and effort that was put into this toy baby.
Verdict: Your Best Baby Dolls That Look Real
Here is the takeaway for the best realistic baby dolls.
If you want the best value for your money, pick the Aori Lifelike Realistic Reborn Baby Doll. This one is very lifelike, and it provides lots of choices for styles, color, and add-ons.
For the best premium, pick the Ashton-Drake Little Peanut Baby Doll. Even though it is the most expensive, it feels like you are holding a real child.
If you are looking for the best gift, pick the Baby Born Interactive Baby Doll. This is the most interactive so if your child wants a baby that does all the things a real one does, look no further.
If you want to spend under $20, pick the JC Toys African American La Baby Doll. It cost less than the others, but it is still made of good quality and has realistic details.
For the best starter baby, pick the JC Toys Anatomically Correct La Newborn Baby Doll. The reason for choosing this one is in the name. It is a great baby for teaching your little one about anatomy and life.
I started with Melissa & Doug babies for my kids because I didn’t know that there were such realistic dolls out there that I could have chosen for them. If I had to make the decision over again, I would pick the Baby Born Interactive doll or the Aori brand because of all of the options for clothes, genders, and ethnicities. It is important to me that my kids are raised to be inclusive, and I like when companies reflect the same values in their products, as a lot of these do.
Each of these babies is a great choice on their own, depending on your preference and the preference of your little ones. I included baby dolls to accommodate any budget and interest, so there is truly something for everyone. Besides, these are great for people who collect them as well. Our babies aren’t babies forever, so it’s no secret that you will get a warm fuzzy feeling while holding these realistic babies.